Kneaded erasers=Mamba fruit candy sticksModel Magic Air Dry Clay=frozen whipped cream or stale marshmallowsmakeup samples=Hawthorn flakesMemory foam=Regent Japanese cheese cake snack cakespacking peanuts=unicorn twist marshmallowsPower cables=TwizzlersDense, slow-rise squishies=Publix brand mini cake donutsChalk discs=Lorna Doone shortbread cookiesGlue sticks=daiya dairy free mozzarella sticks (this one tastes bad)[I don't have an image for this one]
The very fine snow that forms on top of frozen goods stored in the right conditions in a box freezer=RaceTrac Slushie (specifically Sprite flavor)
Styrofoam paper paper plate=Gerrit's Satellite Wafers
I don't have answers for these ones yet
Styrofoam fake cranberries?
Fake plastic scoops of ice cream?
Floral foam? (water chestnuts are close, but too small...not
blocky enough...) (specifically wetfom brand)
Nerf football?
Tiny wrapped presents like what the craft store sells for tiny Christmas trees?
Shaving cream. The closest I have gotten is Borden whipped cream, but exclusively the one they were using at the coffee stand in Animal Kingdom. Every stand uses the same kind, but only that specific one had the exact parameters. maybe it was the matcha combination???
Acrylic paint tubes (specificaly Winsor and Newton Galeria Acrylic)
double-ply crafting foam sheets. I think they're like 2 mm thick
pillar candles
glue sticks for hot glue guns?
Specifically this apple pie scented novelty candle that Michael's got exactly one shipment of and then stopped selling